Shared Top Border
SDCIA logo 11-09-03 cropped small.jpg (4558 bytes) sdcia_head3.jpg (14795 bytes)
A Message Board, Guestbook, or Poll hosted for your website.
SDCIA Message Board

SDCIA > Forums > Discussion Board > Applying for credit cards--What do you do?
 
Username:
Password:
 

Thread Tools Search This Thread 
Reply
 
Author Comment
 
Jeff
Avatar / Picture

Senior Member
Registered: 03/14/05
Posts: 1,464

    03/05/07 at 12:40 PM
Reply with quote#1

I have receiving several more or those 0% cash advance offers lately (you know how I love those).  Anyway, I have a question.

 

In the past I have always reported my w2 income (essentially my salary).  If I wanted to maximize my chances of qualifying I might write down my gross income instead of my taxable income.  But now that I have rental properties, I also have significant 1099 income.  I haven't been reporting this as most of my properties are negative overall...but it IS income.

 

If I report my 1099 income I can nearly double the amount in the "household income" section on the application.  I want my limits to be as high as possible.

 

Does income meaningfully impact your qualifying for credit cards--or raise credit limits?  If so, can you legitimately include 1099 income?

 

What do others do?


__________________
The first million is the hardest...
LoriB
Senior Member
Registered: 05/26/05
Posts: 190

    03/05/07 at 12:56 PM
Reply with quote#2

Didn't you know the whole game is FICO driven? I never heard of Credit Cards using income. I play the FICO game and one of the strongest factors they use is length of account. I keep old cards going. The rate doesn't mean anything to me. Playing the '0' rate game by opening & closing new cards kills your score. The short term benefits don't outweigh the long term.

That income box your eyeing is for marketing purposes only. They sell your application data. Those apps are mining for suckers.

Know how the CC Companies got you in the first place? The Credit Reporting Companies sold your data to them based on your score.

__________________
Know Value or Know Nothing
collinstjohns
Junior Member
Registered: 07/20/06
Posts: 33

    03/05/07 at 01:10 PM
Reply with quote#3

Lori B. hit it on the head - pull your tri merge cred report and you'll probably see that your score is mostly being affected by the number of revolving accounts you have open, etc.  Opening lines for the short term isn't a good idea if you care about preserving a high FICO.

 

To answer your question though - I've always used my gross taxable income....after expenses.

 

If your credit dries up you can run down to B of A, tell them you are new in this country....deposit a few bucks into a checking account...and wait a few months for them to start offering you credit.

BobbiOh
Junior Member
Registered: 12/29/06
Posts: 20

Contact using Yahoo

    03/05/07 at 01:51 PM
Reply with quote#4

Quote:
Originally Posted by LoriB
Playing the '0' rate game by opening & closing new cards kills your score. The short term benefits don't outweigh the long term.
Not to mention that every time it gets looked at shows up and lowers your score too. I was just looking at my credit reports the other days and noticed that they say that inquiries can stay on your report for 2 years. The 3 companies that we shopped our car loan with all appeared and that was mroe than ayear ago. And they differentiate between looks for offers (like unsolicited credit card offers) and applications.

Honestly, what I do to keep the rates low is basically tell them that unless they keep the rate below a certain level, I'm moving the balance to a different card.


__________________
Bobbi

"I'd rather be a lion for one day, than a sheep for my entire life."
Gekko
Avatar / Picture

Senior Member
Registered: 06/27/06
Posts: 758

    03/05/07 at 01:53 PM
Reply with quote#5

 

Jeff - why do you need *more* credit?

 

 

 

LoriB
Senior Member
Registered: 05/26/05
Posts: 190

    03/05/07 at 02:18 PM
Reply with quote#6

I don't think he is looking for more credit. I think he looks for cheap fast cash advances.

__________________
Know Value or Know Nothing
Gekko
Avatar / Picture

Senior Member
Registered: 06/27/06
Posts: 758

    03/05/07 at 02:33 PM
Reply with quote#7

 

same thing.

 

 

dansimo
Avatar / Picture

Senior Member
Registered: 05/25/05
Posts: 625

    03/05/07 at 02:35 PM
Reply with quote#8

I've used them on current cards (not opening new ones) to save on interest payments.
it's worked well...

__________________

"The harder I work, the luckier I get"
steve
Senior Member
Registered: 03/17/05
Posts: 71

    03/05/07 at 05:18 PM
Reply with quote#9

Quote:
Originally Posted by collinstjohns

If your credit dries up you can run down to B of A, tell them you are new in this country....deposit a few bucks into a checking account...and wait a few months for them to start offering you credit.

 

I had both an MBNA  (which was recently purchased by B of A) and B of A credit cards within my 1st month of arriving in the US. B of A required me to maintain a savings account containing my credit limit (i.e. secured debt), but MBNA just gave me a card.

 

Steve

Jeff
Avatar / Picture

Senior Member
Registered: 03/14/05
Posts: 1,464

    03/06/07 at 08:56 PM
Reply with quote#10

Quote:
Originally Posted by Gekko

 

Jeff - why do you need *more* credit?

 

 

 

Hey I just want the 0% cash advances to put into EmigrantDirect at 5%.  I am doing my taxes and just found out I made $2600 last year doing this "creative" rearranging of debt.

 

The "best" deal right now is a credit card at EmigrantDirect.  They are offering me a 0% cash advance rate.  The cool part is that I could be borrowing from EmigrantDirect and then loaning them their own money back at 5%...

 

Or now that I am hitting my HELOC on my primary at 7.75%, I could simply pay this down (temporarily) with the 0% money and be making even more(?).  Is a 7.75% rate on a tax deductible loan better than a 5% return that is taxed?  How do you calculate that?


__________________
The first million is the hardest...
dansimo
Avatar / Picture

Senior Member
Registered: 05/25/05
Posts: 625

    03/06/07 at 11:18 PM
Reply with quote#11

I love that!



__________________

"The harder I work, the luckier I get"
hessj
Senior Member
Registered: 06/25/06
Posts: 140

    03/07/07 at 12:25 AM
Reply with quote#12

JEFF UR THE MAN!!!

2Encinitas
Avatar / Picture

Senior Member
Registered: 10/26/05
Posts: 503

Contact using Skype

    03/07/07 at 08:35 AM
Reply with quote#13

Jeff,

 

I do the same thing. 


__________________
Todd Toback
"The Lease Purchase Guy"
For a free CD and a copy of our newsletter go to:
http://www.toddtoback.com
http://www.leasepurchasecoach.blogspot.com
http://www.theleasepurchasecoach.com
cal
Avatar / Picture

Senior Member
Registered: 04/04/06
Posts: 127

    03/07/07 at 12:06 PM
Reply with quote#14

Quote:

Jeff said "Hey I just want the 0% cash advances to put into EmigrantDirect at 5%.  I am doing my taxes and just found out I made $2600 last year doing this "creative" rearranging of debt."

 

"The "best" deal right now is a credit card at EmigrantDirect.  They are offering me a 0% cash advance rate.  The cool part is that I could be borrowing from EmigrantDirect and then loaning them their own money back at 5%..."

 

 

Either I'm a fool or Jeff is much smarter than me...But this just sounds ridiculous......I think you could spend your time doing something more profitable.......How does a massive amount of dept equate to income?   Just one last thing....Since when has a creditor cared about your income anyway.......Just make up whatever you want.....It's not like they really care as long as you have been paying your bills on time..... 

BayPark
Avatar / Picture

Senior Member
Registered: 08/22/06
Posts: 255

    03/07/07 at 12:10 PM
Reply with quote#15

Quote:
Originally Posted by cal

Jeff said "Hey I just want the 0% cash advances to put into EmigrantDirect at 5%. I am doing my taxes and just found out I made $2600 last year doing this "creative" rearranging of debt."

"The "best" deal right now is a credit card at EmigrantDirect. They are offering me a 0% cash advance rate. The cool part is that I could be borrowing from EmigrantDirect and then loaning them their own money back at 5%..."

Either I'm a fool or Jeff is much smarter than me...But this just sounds ridiculous......I think you could spend your time doing something more profitable.......How does a massive amount of dept equate to income?



Suppose Jeff borrows 50,000 at 0% and puts it in an account that earns 5%. At the end of 1 year Jeff has about 52,500 in the savings account.
Poof: $2500 of free money. At the end of the 0% rate period he can pay off the debt with the amount in savings.

This is called interest rate arbitrage.   It probably takes less than an hour or two to do this over the coarse of a year, including the time it takes to set up automatic minimum payments to the credit card company.    Pretty good payoff for a short amount of time.

Hey, if someone is willing to hand you a couple thousand dollars for a couple hours of work, would you take it. 
cal
Avatar / Picture

Senior Member
Registered: 04/04/06
Posts: 127

    03/07/07 at 12:15 PM
Reply with quote#16

Quote:
"Suppose Jeff borrows 50,000 at 0% and puts it in an account that earns 5%. At the end of 1 year Jeff has about 52,500 in the savings account. Poof: $2500 of free money. At the end of the 0% rate period he can pay off the debt with the amount in savings. This is called interest rate arbitrage."

Ya right........Someone is going to let him borrow 50,000 at 0% interest!!!!

BayPark
Avatar / Picture

Senior Member
Registered: 08/22/06
Posts: 255

    03/07/07 at 02:28 PM
Reply with quote#17

Quote:
Originally Posted by cal

Quote:
"Suppose Jeff borrows 50,000 at 0% and puts it in an account that earns 5%. At the end of 1 year Jeff has about 52,500 in the savings account. Poof: $2500 of free money. At the end of the 0% rate period he can pay off the debt with the amount in savings. This is called interest rate arbitrage."

Ya right........Someone is going to let him borrow 50,000 at 0% interest!!!!



About 7 years ago I used a 0% interest credit card offer for about 16K for 9 months.  I would not be surprised if someone could get 50K or more.
Gekko
Avatar / Picture

Senior Member
Registered: 06/27/06
Posts: 758

    03/07/07 at 02:39 PM
Reply with quote#18

 

 

are you sure the 0% interest rate includes cash advances?  usually it's just for balance transfers from actual purchases.

 

 

Jeff
Avatar / Picture

Senior Member
Registered: 03/14/05
Posts: 1,464

    03/07/07 at 03:26 PM
Reply with quote#19

Quote:
Originally Posted by cal

Quote:
"Suppose Jeff borrows 50,000 at 0% and puts it in an account that earns 5%. At the end of 1 year Jeff has about 52,500 in the savings account. Poof: $2500 of free money. At the end of the 0% rate period he can pay off the debt with the amount in savings. This is called interest rate arbitrage."

Ya right........Someone is going to let him borrow 50,000 at 0% interest!!!!

You sound incredulous.  I didn't believe it either the first time I got this offer (about 10 years ago?).  But I assure you, several of my cards regularly offer me 0% interest loans up to my credit limit (50k on one card).

 

Remember, this is just a teaser rate.  Their hopes are that I will keep the debt after the 6 month period.

 

Their hopes are in vain.


__________________
The first million is the hardest...
Jeff
Avatar / Picture

Senior Member
Registered: 03/14/05
Posts: 1,464

    03/07/07 at 03:32 PM
Reply with quote#20

Quote:
Originally Posted by Gekko

 

 

are you sure the 0% interest rate includes cash advances?  usually it's just for balance transfers from actual purchases.

 

 

Different cards have different rules.  The most recent offers did not require that the loans be in the form of balance transfers, but earlier ones did. 

 

If a balance transfer is required, I simply have them send the money to a card that I owe little on.  Then I contact that card and tell them I overpaid my account and ask them to cut me a check.  The check arrives a few days (weeks?) later.  A little more work but worth it if it pays off...


__________________
The first million is the hardest...
reijoe
Senior Member
Registered: 03/08/06
Posts: 693

    03/07/07 at 03:41 PM
Reply with quote#21

Quote:
Originally Posted by Gekko

are you sure the 0% interest rate includes cash advances? usually it's just for balance transfers from actual purchases.



You are right in that some of them (maybe all) don't apply to cash advances.

They usually apply to balance transfers. However, you don't have to actually transfer a balance from one card to another to take advantage of this promotion. You can simply transfer the "balance" from your bank account. Then you can do whatever you want with the money. Some cards even send you those checks in the mail, and if you use them in a certain way then they act as a balance transfer. Just write one out to yourself and cash it. Here's another tip, I had a customer rep tell me that sometimes you can get a cheaper transaction fee for a balance transfer if you do it over the phone.

I received one of these offers in the mail once and called the company to ask about the details. I got the rep on the phone to be candid with me and she basically said that yes, it's a marketing plot to get people to build a balance on the card. But they are relying on 90% of the people who take this offer to screw up and ultimately get charged higher rates. Most of these offers states that you have to make a certain number of purchases each billing cycle. And that any payments you make go towards the lowest % blance (i.e. the 0% balance) before higher % balances. So to make the deal work, you have to buy 1 pack of gum 2x each month or something. Otherwise, your rate jumps. Or if you miss even 1 payment, the rate jumps, etc. So it's a big game, but if you can set it up so that the monthly purchases and monthly payments are automated, then it's easy free money.
duane1x
Senior Member
Registered: 08/15/06
Posts: 161

    03/07/07 at 03:50 PM
Reply with quote#22

Quote:
Originally Posted by cal

Ya right........Someone is going to let him borrow 50,000 at 0% interest!!!!

 

That is what the offers say. I get 'em too. I had one offer recently that had a date over 12 months out at 0%.

 

Anyway, I have always been dissuaded by the actual mechanics - payments will be applied to lowest % first - rates jump off the chart at first payment glitch. Plus the point that it's to consolidate other debt, not to buy a CD - don't know if they require any docs on that, but I think the bean counters have spring loaded this thing in the event you step one toe off the path.

 

Jeff I'd be careful of the fine print especially if it's an existing card you use regularly - the only way I considered it was with a new card that I never planned to use for anything else. In the end it seems like too much work.

 

 

duane1x
Senior Member
Registered: 08/15/06
Posts: 161

    03/07/07 at 03:54 PM
Reply with quote#23

Quote:
Originally Posted by reijoe

Here's another tip, I had a customer rep tell me that sometimes you can get a cheaper transaction fee for a balance transfer if you do it over the phone.

 

Thanks for reminding me. The one I took the time to decipher had a 2 or 3% fee. So there's half your CD rate, right there.

dansimo
Avatar / Picture

Senior Member
Registered: 05/25/05
Posts: 625

    03/07/07 at 05:30 PM
Reply with quote#24

Quote:
Originally Posted by cal

Either I'm a fool or Jeff is much smarter than me...But this just sounds ridiculous......I think you could spend your time doing something more profitable.......How does a massive amount of dept equate to income?



It's called ARBITRAGE!


__________________

"The harder I work, the luckier I get"
Jeff
Avatar / Picture

Senior Member
Registered: 03/14/05
Posts: 1,464

    03/07/07 at 10:25 PM
Reply with quote#25

Quote:
Originally Posted by duane1x

Quote:
Originally Posted by reijoe

Here's another tip, I had a customer rep tell me that sometimes you can get a cheaper transaction fee for a balance transfer if you do it over the phone.

 

Thanks for reminding me. The one I took the time to decipher had a 2 or 3% fee. So there's half your CD rate, right there.

For my offers, the 3% "transaction fee" was capped at $75...more than worth it for over $200 a month in interest...


__________________
The first million is the hardest...
2Encinitas
Avatar / Picture

Senior Member
Registered: 10/26/05
Posts: 503

Contact using Skype

    03/07/07 at 10:58 PM
Reply with quote#26

You can laugh all you want, I get these offers all the time and take advantage of them.  Then I take the interest, and invest in prosper at 25% interest.  Hey need a loan???? 

Quote:
Originally Posted by cal

Quote:
"Suppose Jeff borrows 50,000 at 0% and puts it in an account that earns 5%. At the end of 1 year Jeff has about 52,500 in the savings account. Poof: $2500 of free money. At the end of the 0% rate period he can pay off the debt with the amount in savings. This is called interest rate arbitrage."

Ya right........Someone is going to let him borrow 50,000 at 0% interest!!!!


__________________
Todd Toback
"The Lease Purchase Guy"
For a free CD and a copy of our newsletter go to:
http://www.toddtoback.com
http://www.leasepurchasecoach.blogspot.com
http://www.theleasepurchasecoach.com
duane1x
Senior Member
Registered: 08/15/06
Posts: 161

    03/08/07 at 06:50 AM
Reply with quote#27

Todd, how about an update on your prosper experience?

cal
Avatar / Picture

Senior Member
Registered: 04/04/06
Posts: 127

    03/08/07 at 09:07 AM
Reply with quote#28

It sounds like the credit card companies are going to make this very difficult to maintain the 0% interest with all the hoops you have to go through.....Along with damaging your credit score every time you get a new credit card......I think as an investor your credit score is going to be very important as they tighten up on loaning money........I doubt anyone here can make this work with just a few hours of work!  But good luck.......By the way what is 2,500.00 when you are losing 5,000 per month.....

reijoe
Senior Member
Registered: 03/08/06
Posts: 693

    03/08/07 at 01:49 PM
Reply with quote#29

Quote:
Originally Posted by cal
By the way what is 2,500.00 when you are losing 5,000 per month.....


It's 1/2 a month of reprieve.
2Encinitas
Avatar / Picture

Senior Member
Registered: 10/26/05
Posts: 503

Contact using Skype

    03/08/07 at 02:25 PM
Reply with quote#30

My proper performance is Still the same.  My lifetime performance is around 23% annually, but to be fair I have only been doing it for about six months.  I will post under the prosper forum every quarter or so and not to bore you every month.

 

And actually the whole thing with the credit cards takes me about 15 minutes.  I just write one of the access checks they give me and deposit into my saving account.  Then I just put the date of the the end of the APR in my calender and pay it off when the intro is over. 

 

I am sorry if you think that it takes more then a couple of hours.  I don't understand why people blast other people for a little success.  Jeff, sorry to Hijack your thread, but I don't undserstand why people are so negative.  Jeff has been through some serious financial training from his days at Taco Bell

 

They look for every reason why it won't work and they never look for a way to make it work.

 

And in terms of credit..I don't think has affected Jeff.  He has houses all over the country.  Probably more then 95% of the people who are on this board.  I don't get new credit cards, I just use it with the ones I already have and just use one card for purchases, the other for cash advances to put into my bank account.

 

 


__________________
Todd Toback
"The Lease Purchase Guy"
For a free CD and a copy of our newsletter go to:
http://www.toddtoback.com
http://www.leasepurchasecoach.blogspot.com
http://www.theleasepurchasecoach.com
Previous Thread | Next Thread
Page 1 of 2   1  |  2 > 
Reply

 
Bookmarks
 
Digg Diggdel.icio.us del.icio.usStumbleUpon StumbleUponGoogle Google
 

Policy